Wednesday, March 2, 2011

February's Hottest Blogs: Dreams in the Lich House, Yaqqothl Grimoire!

Here's a list of 243 old schoolish roleplaying blogs ranked by the number of followers they gained between January 31st and March 1st. I rank blogs using this system - as opposed to raw follower number - in order to determine which blogs are "hottest" without being biased by how long a blog has been around. My main motivation for making this list is to highlight the blogs that are currently attracting the most reader attention regardless of the blogs' age. Out of respect, I DO NOT list blogs with zero or negative growth.

My usual blogometric caveats apply: (1) This list only has blogger.com blogs because follower numbers are not publicly available for WordPress blogs. (2) Yes, I know some blogs are missing. If your blog is on my big blog list as of today, it should be in the next ranking. If your blog is not on my list and you want to be included, please email me the link through my profile.

Last month's hottest blog was Dreams in the Lich House. This is a straight-up excellent blog focusing on classic D&D via the popular Lamentations of the Flame Princess retroclone. It has a good mix of opinion, creative content, and session reports. It also won Gothridge Manor's Newbie Blogger Award for February. Keep it up, Beedo!

The next hottest blog of the month was The Yaqqothl Grimoire, which focuses on classic D&D with a weird fantasy twist. Il Male writes great stuff and is super prolific. I highly recommend this awesome blog!

Other younger blogs that topped the list were Rather Gamey, A Pack of Gnolls (also a winner of the Newbie Blogger Award), Hack & Slash, and Gorgonmilk. Be sure to give them all a click (YES - you can click on the blog names below, they are all links)!


Blog Name
1-Mar
31-Jan
Change
80
46
34
47
14
33
813
783
30
58
28
30
30
5
25
54
31
23
54
32
22
641
619
22
140
119
21
247
227
20
129
109
20
111
91
20
160
141
19
122
103
19
233
214
19
305
288
17
172
155
17
139
122
17
143
126
17
138
122
16
99
84
15
54
39
15
66
52
14
14
0
14
91
77
14
165
152
13
78
65
13
429
416
13
33
20
13
47
34
13
95
83
12
118
106
12
45
33
12
268
256
12
141
129
12
60
48
12
136
124
12
97
85
12
61
49
12
122
110
12
246
235
11
47
36
11
224
213
11
116
105
11
354
343
11
122
111
11
153
142
11
99
89
10
75
65
10
40
30
10
52
43
9
189
180
9
91
82
9
66
57
9
61
52
9
166
157
9
228
219
9
41
33
8
20
12
8
88
80
8
61
53
8
188
180
8
29
21
8
28
20
8
32
24
8
8
0
8
118
111
7
22
15
7
45
38
7
112
105
7
29
22
7
22
15
7
138
131
7
140
133
7
60
53
7
208
201
7
105
98
7
46
39
7
161
154
7
68
61
7
46
39
7
195
188
7
28
22
6
101
95
6
177
171
6
54
48
6
218
212
6
21
15
6
66
60
6
125
119
6
36
30
6
62
56
6
119
113
6
40
34
6
114
109
5
30
25
5
47
42
5
245
240
5
41
36
5
57
52
5
35
30
5
138
133
5
98
93
5
120
115
5
156
151
5
195
190
5
24
19
5
50
45
5
51
46
5
95
90
5
175
170
5
44
39
5
70
65
5
93
88
5
38
34
4
32
28
4
90
86
4
20
16
4
36
32
4
56
52
4
50
46
4
17
13
4
73
69
4
19
15
4
48
44
4
37
33
4
138
134
4
5
1
4
12
8
4
28
24
4
29
25
4
22
18
4
73
69
4
36
32
4
43
39
4
109
105
4
91
87
4
60
56
4
27
23
4
141
137
4
17
13
4
78
74
4
98
94
4
73
69
4
100
96
4
7
3
4
51
48
3
40
37
3
56
53
3
53
50
3
116
113
3
62
59
3
19
16
3
83
80
3
64
61
3
21
18
3
16
13
3
37
34
3
48
45
3
52
49
3
150
147
3
57
54
3
58
55
3
9
6
3
49
46
3
42
39
3
199
196
3
13
10
3
40
37
3
70
67
3
48
45
3
38
35
3
21
18
3
54
51
3
134
131
3
3
0
3
19
16
3
6
3
3
45
42
3
49
46
3
23
20
3
18
15
3
49
47
2
2
0
2
30
28
2
54
52
2
48
46
2
36
34
2
24
22
2
48
46
2
37
35
2
25
23
2
17
15
2
14
12
2
35
33
2
46
44
2
86
84
2
40
38
2
56
54
2
37
35
2
56
54
2
44
42
2
36
34
2
6
4
2
15
13
2
28
26
2
30
28
2
76
74
2
79
77
2
78
76
2
13
12
1
36
35
1
26
25
1
14
13
1
35
34
1
19
18
1
75
74
1
26
25
1
24
23
1
23
22
1
38
37
1
45
44
1
35
34
1
7
6
1
24
23
1
25
24
1
14
13
1
16
15
1
28
27
1
14
13
1
72
71
1
64
63
1
40
39
1
129
128
1
26
25
1
18
17
1
9
8
1
48
47
1
7
6
1
9
8
1
50
49
1
50
49
1
37
36
1

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

"He probably plays Dungeons & Dragons..."

Not long ago I was at a dinner party with some academic colleagues. Because many academics fancy themselves gourmets we strayed to the topic of sharpening fine cutlery. The hostess mentioned that down the street there was a guy whose hobby is sharpening knives. In fact, every weekend you can see him in his garage sharpening things.

She said "Yeah, he's really weird. He probably plays Dungeons & Dragons."

This was such a perfectly timed comment because no less then four of us in that room full of wine-sipping university professors play D&D together regularly. I guess we just don't really advertise the fact at work that we like to pretend we're goblin-fighting wizards while we sip our wine. I just stayed quiet, concerned that my secret life as a "dungeon master" might be revealed before I go up for tenure.

After a moment the geologist in the room spoke up and said "Hey! We play Dungeons & Dragons!"

The hostess smiled and said something like "Ohh.. Hah hah. Hummm..."

Who "we" referred to remained vague. I stayed quiet, just sipping my wine, while the conversation moved on. I guess it's still a mystery around here, then, who's rolling d20s in the closet... and who their master is...

Monday, February 28, 2011

Facebook and Twitter Killing Blogs

A week ago NY Times published a story "Blogs Wane as the Young Drift to Sites Like Twitter". This article cites surveys and anecdotal interviews showing how younger people are giving up blogging in favor of Twitter, Tumblr, and Facebook. I guess most of what these young internet migrants have to say to the world fits into 1-2 sentences. Or less:
"Kim Hou, a high school senior in San Francisco, said she quit blogging months ago, but acknowledged that she continued to post fashion photos on Tumblr. “It’s different from blogging because it’s easier to use,” she said. “With blogging you have to write, and this is just images. Some people write some phrases or some quotes, but that’s it.”"
No offense to any of you tweeters or fb'ers out there, but I personally cannot get into Twitter or Facebook much. As a matter of fact, I often find them depressing because they make a lot of the people I know seem a bit dull even when they're not. I mean, how much can one say in 140 characters? One little poop-pellet of mundane boringness, most likely. Unless you're a brilliant poet. I haven't friended any brilliant poets on Facebook yet. In the mean time, I don't care what my 3rd-grade friend had for lunch.

Another thing I don't like about Facebook is that I can't be anonymous there. Ironically, I feel like I can be much more anonymous on my blog. On Facebook I have to worry about a strange and uncomfortable mix of family, professional colleagues, and weird friends mingling around my posts. I really don't want my mom or co-workers reading about my frenzied alcohol-fueled nights of pretending I'm an elf. Here on Cyclopeatron only a few weird friends and Canadian strangers read my crap. I know this because I have Sitemeter. Is it healthy that I prefer babbling to strangers? Probably not... But I guess this is preferred by all you other geriatrics:
"While the younger generation is losing interest in blogging, people approaching middle age and older are sticking with it. Among 34-to-45-year-olds who use the Internet, the percentage who blog increased six points, to 16 percent, in 2010 from two years earlier, the Pew survey found. Blogging by 46-to-55-year-olds increased five percentage points, to 11 percent, while blogging among 65-to-73-year-olds rose two percentage points, to 8 percent. "
I won't name names, but several blogs that I've enjoyed in the past have gone silent, but I still see the (ex-)bloggers posting all over FB (pictures of ferrets in one case, perhaps? ;) ). Too bad...

Boot Hill First Printing + Vintage Miniatures

A few weeks ago I made a lucky score on eBay. For $36 I got three 1970s Tactical Studies Rules books: Chainmail, D&D Blackmoor, and Boot Hill. They are all well-loved copies with writing in them which is something I prefer.

The most rare and remarkable of the three books is Boot Hill, which is a first printing from 1975. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that this is the third roleplaying game ever published, behind Dungeons & Dragons and Empire of the Petal Throne. This little brown book is pretty hard to find, especially with the tear-out reference sheets still intact. I have to admit that I've never been terribly interested in Boot Hill or any other historical games because wizards and weird science are my thing. This game looks like a lot of fun though, and I could see myself running a few weird west shoot outs in the near future.

I also picked up some early 1980s Boot Hill minis off eBay for $1. Cool!

Here are pictures of the artifacts...

CLICK IMAGES TO ENLARGE


Unlike most of the other little TSR books from the period, Boot Hill includes numerous ready-to-go maps, scenarios, and NPCs.:

Rare double-page tear-out reference sheet:

TSR Boot Hill minis c. 1983:



Friday, February 25, 2011

The Best Magic Sword Description Ever Written

"Nobody can tell you about that sword all that there is to be told of it; for those that know of those paths of Space on which its metals once floated, till Earth caught them one by one as she sailed past on her orbit, have little time to waste on such things as magic, and so cannot tell you how the sword was made, and those who know whence poetry is, and the need that man has for song, or know any one of the fifty branches of magic, have little time to waste on such things as science, and so cannot tell you whence its ingredients came.

Enough that it was once beyond our Earth and was now here amongst our mundane stones; that it was once but as those stones, and now had something in it such as soft music has; let those that can define it."

- Lord Dunsany, The King of Elfland's Daughter (1924)

Thursday, February 24, 2011

John Thor vs. Satan

I kind of thought my Gamma World Mutants of Metal setting was slightly original. It turns out I was totally fooling myself. Troy Z. sent me a link to this footage of national treasure John Thor fighting Satan in the rare 1987 movie Rock 'n' Roll Nightmare:



Here are some awesome clips representing other aspects of Thor's career. Talk about 18 STR coupled with various mental mutations...

"Is this a band of heavy metal music? How about I do some metal bending?" he asks during a concert just before... bending metal:



A moustachioed Thor uses oral gas generation to explode a hot water bottle on the Merv Griffin show:

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Further Thoughts on Mouse Guard

In my Orccon 2011 recap a few days ago I mentioned that I played in a Mouse Guard game, and that I found the game to be frustratingly slow and I would not be inclined to play again. Somehow, within hours, my post found itself relayed on the Mouse Guard discussion forum, and the GM of the session chimed in on my comments. Out of respect for the GM, I thought I’d take a minute to better describe my impression of the session and of The Burning Wheel rule system on which Mouse Guard is based.

Facts about the game:
1. I did enjoy the game in several ways (see below).
2. The GM was skilled, experienced, and confident.
3. The GM was pleased with how the session went.
4. The players were all experienced gamers and were also satisfied with how the session went.
5. We played for 3-4 hours.
6. In this time we roleplayed three distinct situations: (1) freed a cart from mud, (2) unsuccessfully searched for a person in a town, (3) had an argument with a group of NPCs..

Soo... basically each situation in this game took, on average, over an hour to get through. Given that this was in line with the expectations of the GM and the players - i.e. the session wasn’t a dud, it was a good game - I think the root of my problem came down to the fact that Mouse Guard’s hyper-micro-management approach to roleplaying was not my personal cup of tea. I constantly work to speed up my games so players feel like they are stepping into exciting, fast-moving stories. I like old school and rules-light RPGs because they facilitate narrative speed, and, at their best, produce an imagination-fueled feeling of entrainment, momentum, and immersion that is unique to RPGs.

The Burning Wheel rule system takes a very different approach to roleplaying. It makes players deconstruct trivial tasks into long series of dice pool roles constructed by combinations of players’ Traits, Abilities, Skills, and various modifiers – all translated in the context of a list of Beliefs, Goals, and Instincts unique to each player. I admit that there was some fun in juggling numbers around to justify every few sentences of roleplaying. The feeling was a lot like playing a strategy eurogame – you have to choose from a small set of available actions (i.e. what Trait or Skill are you going to use and possibly burn) and then act on the outcome of the scaled dicepool and possibly accrue some future modifiers (Fate, Persona, Checks, etc.). Based on the dicepool outcome (failures ~80% of the time) the narrative changes direction for a few sentences from the GM, then you repeat. I like eurogames, so I did derive some enjoyment from this odd rpg/eurogame hybrid experience.

But the simple fact remains… It took well over an hour and ~20 dice pool roles to have a first-person roleplay argument with an opponent NPC. It was a weird microscopic dissection of a game moment that would be 5-10 minutes of free-form first-person roleplaying in a traditional RPG. While The Burning Wheel rule system is clever and novel, I think this snail-paced roleplaying would get old very quickly. Playing a “campaign” like this would be absolutely excruciating, in my opinion.

Another impression I was left with was that this rule system disrespects players in a strange kind of way. Instead of allowing players to roleplay their characters’ personalities however they feel is appropriate, players constantly strive to take actions that align with (or in some numerically optimal situations, contradict) their Beliefs, Goals, Instincts, and Nature as outlined on the characters sheet. The better one plays this game, the more Fate and Persona points are collected from the GM to modify dice pool roles. A major downside to this is that in most situations it is glaringly obvious what Ability or Skill (or whatever) is most optimal to use, so the game mechanic kind of plays the characters in an almost puppet-like way.

In sum, Mouse Guard is indeed a slow moving roleplaying game. It magnifies normally trivial roleplaying situations into long series of statistical number-crunching dicepools that determine the direction of the narrative and push PCs through situations like number-optimized puppets. I think of this game as a novel hybrid between eurogames and RPGs, and it has some entertaining merits in this respect. If I wanted to run an exciting adventure based on the Mouse Guard comic book, however, there is no way I would use these rules.

NOTE: I just want to thank the GM again for an excellent introduction to Mouse Guard and emphasize that this post is about game mechanics, not his GMing skills. As I said before, he's a skilled and confident GM.